Crest vs Colgate - A Fight to the End!

Reasons why Crest might be better, in general

Crest better impresses with its stannous fluoride offerings. Crest also offers more erosion prevention. It also carries an unmatched, highly potential tin element making this possible. Crest is softer on those pearly whites, as well, as we’ll discuss in further scope. For another look at this same thing, check out our other article: Crest vs Colgate.

Reasons Colgate might be better, in general

Colgate uses more triclosan. This more effectively treats gingivitis. Colgate also boasts of stronger antibacterial agents and properties within its every product. The FDA has found Colgate’s more effective in this respect. Colgate sells slightly more products, making a few more sales.

Which is more popular?

Honestly speaking, it’s a hard fight. The winning champion is still an unsettled one though a strong handful of research experts would say that it’s Colgate, which is more commercially successful and even meets sales quotas a bit more richly. Both brands are known as the top two leading brands in America. They take the U.S. --- and even the world --- by storm, each with its own appeal and approach to teeth whitening and a fresher breath for all. Yet Colgate, after all, stands a little higher.

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for whitening teeth?

Colgate is known to hold the upper hand here, at least as it relates to this question, simply due to the fact that it strays from stannous fluoride which --- as you guessed --- is known to stain teeth over time. Crest is all about using stannous fluoride for its many benefits, disregarding this slight disadvantage. In addition, research has found that those using too much stannous fluoride tend to experience their gums sloughing off a bit.

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for sensitive teeth?

User testimonials hold that both are good for this, but that Crest, this time, holds a key advantage. It shows more poise and a more sensitive feel with its passing strokes, assuming the user is not hard-brushing, of course. All it takes is a gentle touch, and that is even why many dentists add Crest filaments within many of their commercial products, those for surgical use and those otherwise.

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for preventing cavities?

The people, of course, remain undecided, but the dental experts themselves --- once again --- would make a strong case for Crest this time, so sorry, Colgate. Don’t get me wrong: Colgate also holds many strong points here but does not quite match up to Crest’s reputation, and the statistics never lie.

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for bad breath?

Once again, watch out for bad breath and even gum sloughing --- in other words, this is when the thin surface layers of their gums begin to gradually peel away. This happens slightly more with Crest’s products, according to recent studies, yet other expert opinions would differ and require further scrutiny. Colgate wins!

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for bad enamel?

Colgate seems to be well ahead of its competition, once more, as it relates to this intricate detail as well since it even lets its own users and prospects feel out --- with their own hands and for themselves --- just what they can come to expect in using its products. Here is how this happens: First, consumers try demo. products in which they touch and feel both smooth and rough enamel, thus making their own comparison and self-reinforcing their brand imagery. Colgate has nothing to hide here, it seems.

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for fighting gingivitis?

Did you know the original Colgate Total Classic Toothpaste is one of the FDA’s favorites? It has indeed escaped the naughty list and is the only gingivitis-preventing toothpaste, marked by the FDA as such? So, the FDA hasn’t ultimately concluded, once and for all, with complete and total finality, that other products can do the same. That itself is quite a milestone achievement, to say the very least.

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for fighting plaque?

This one’s perhaps a close tie, too, but it’s been found that various versions of the Colgate Total product have earned their rightful acceptance of a valid Seal of Approval, from none other than the ADA, in terms of most effective plaque control. The product uses a generous amount of Triclosan, which is a strong antibacterial and antiplaque compound. More so, various versions of Crest’s competing Pro-Health product promise to do the same, which they do, but not on the same level --- the results show.

Crest/Colgate: Which is better for tartar control?

Both fight tartar well, but Crest does it a little better, in the opinion of several. This is perhaps because Crest carries its own product that does this very thing --- control tartar. In fact, the product is called Crest Tartar Protection Toothpaste, and it currently rates at four stars and higher on multiple review sites, including Amazon and Ebay. So once again, the numbers cannot lie, but this is not to say that Colgate doesn’t have effective tartar control within its many products, but it seems Crest certainly specializes in this realm a little more.

Don't forget to check out Crest vs Colgate.

Final Word

Crest better impresses with its stannous fluoride offerings. Crest also offers more erosion prevention. Yet Colgate uses more triclosan. This more effectively treats gingivitis. Colgate also boasts of stronger antibacterial agents and properties within its every product. So which one is it, after all? Though Colgate makes more sales and offers a bit more behind each product sale, it still appears the victory is minimal. Crest is truly not too far behind and can catch up in an instant, if Colgate should ever drop its guard. Close match, indeed! But don’t let the sway of the media convince you of which brand is best. Visit the store or browse online to make your own decision on this matter. Try both brands, in the long run, and see which you prefer to stick with. It’s all a matter of preference, so which of America’s two favorite brands will you be going with? Or will it be both?